Call now for a no-charge, no-obligation case evaluation.

Self-Checkout at Wal-mart Results in More Theft Charges

     Wal-mart's recent introduction of self-checkout services has resulted in more theft charges for customers.  Self-checkout allows customers to scan merchandise themselves and pay for the merchandise without the assistance of a store clerk. The benefit of this system is that the store can have more check-out stations open for customers without paying cashiers to staff the registers.  More check-out stations means less wait-time in check-out lines for customers.  Self-checkout saves Wal-mart staff expenses.

     However, self-checkout comes with a cost for Wal-mart.  Self-checkout is vulnerable to intentional abuse and mistakes by customers during the check-out process.  Wal-mart loss prevention staff in Salisbury and Fruitland, Maryland, report that they have seen an increase in thefts by customers using the self-checkout stations.  It is not hard to imagine how easy it is for customers to bag merchandise without scanning all of their items.  A customer who does this intentionally commits the crime of theft when they leave the store without paying for the unscanned items. Of course, it is also possible for customers to mistakenly fail to scan an item or two during the check-out process.  Failing to pay for an item due to a genuine mistake is not theft because theft requires an intent to steal.  The difficulty faced by Wal-mart loss prevention staff, criminal prosecutors, defense attorneys, judges and juries is determining when the failure to scan an item at self-checkout was intentional and when it was an honest mistake.  This can be a very subjective conclusion that must be made based on circumstantial evidence unless there is an admission by the customer that he intended to steal (which is unlikely).  At least the State has the burden of proving that the defendant is guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.  But this is not much solace for the innocent customer who mistakenly fails to scan an item and finds himself charged with theft, hiring a lawyer, and going to court with his freedom and reputation on the line.

     I was recently in the Wicomico County District Court waiting for my case to be called by the State when I watched a college student attempt to represent herself in court.  She was charged with theft for stealing from Wal-mart at a self-checkout station.  She did not have an attorney.  She plead guilty.  The prosecutor read the statement of facts to support her conviction reciting how she did not scan merchandise at the Wal-mart self-checkout station.  Then the defendant proceeded to tell the judge that she made an honest mistake when she failed to scan her alleged stolen items.  The judge asked her why she was pleading guilty.  She said because it was her responsibility to scan all the items and she didn't.  The judge refused to accept her guilty plea, postponed her case and told her to get an attorney.  This young lady needed a good defense attorney to guide her through the criminal justice system and defend her in court.  She had a defense to the theft charge that she wasn't even aware of because she did not have an attorney.

     As our society becomes more automated, opportunities arise to abuse these convenient systems for personal advantage.  However, these systems also create situations that embroil inncoent persons in the criminal justice system. This is yet another reason why a person charged with a theft crime should retain a good criminal defense attorney. 

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Contact Us To Discuss Your Options

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Get In Touch

Salisbury Office
208 Calvert Street
P.O. Box 33
Salisbury, MD 21801

Toll Free: 866-242-3785
Phone: 410-713-4465
Salisbury Law Office Map

Ocean City Office
9307 Chesapeake Drive
Unit D5904
Ocean City, MD 21842

Map & Directions

  • We offer free consultations for criminal cases, And we accept multiple payment methods, including MasterCard, Visa and Discover.
  • Spanish-language translation services are available / Servicios del intérprete disponibles.